Caps and hurdles: keep the cost of your plan predictable
Two settings decide what a grant can be worth: where participants start to share, and where it stops. Set them well and both sides know where they stand.
On this page
The first question shareholders ask about a virtual share plan is rarely about the team. It is: what is the potential cost? The honest answer is that it depends on two settings. A hurdle decides from which value participants start to share. A cap decides where it stops.
Principle
Why limits make a plan stronger
Limits sound like a way to give less. In practice they make a plan easier to agree on. Shareholders can approve a plan whose maximum cost they know. A cap is also fairer to the people who stay, because one reward cannot come at the cost of what everyone else is building towards. And participants get a reward that is tied to something they can influence: the growth from the moment they joined.
Hurdle
The hurdle: growth from today
With a hurdle, participants only share in value above a set starting value. In most plans that is the value on the day of the grant, also called the price at grant. Someone who joins when the company is already worth a lot then does not receive a share of value that was built before them.
This is the difference between two terms you will see often. Phantom shares give a share of the full value. Stock appreciation rights only give a share of the growth. A SAR is simply a virtual share with a hurdle.
A higher hurdle for later grants
Because the hurdle follows the value at grant, people who join later automatically start from a higher point. That keeps early and late participants fair towards each other without extra rules.
Cap
The cap: a known maximum
A cap sets the maximum value a grant can reach at a payout. You can set it in two ways:
- A maximum price per virtual share. Above that price, the value of each virtual share stops growing.
- A maximum company value. The plan calculates the value of a virtual share as if the company were sold for at most that amount.
Above the cap, the extra value goes to the shareholders only. The cap only works upwards: if the company is worth less, participants receive less, just like shareholders.
Example
One grant, three outcomes
Take a participant with 1,000 virtual shares. At the grant, one share is worth €40. Years later the company is sold at €100 per share.
- Full value, no limits: 1,000 × €100 = €100,000.
- With a hurdle at €40: 1,000 × (€100 − €40) = €60,000.
- With a hurdle at €40 and a cap at €80: 1,000 × (€80 − €40) = €40,000.
The figures are only an illustration. The point is that each setting changes the outcome a lot, so it is worth showing people worked examples like this before they sign.
Related limits
Other limits in a plan
The size of the pool
The pool sets the total number of virtual shares the plan can hand out, compared with the real shares. It limits the total share participants can have together. How to size it is a question of its own, covered in how many shares to grant.
The leaver cap
A leaver cap only applies to people who leave on good terms. It fixes the maximum value of their vested virtual shares at the value on the leaving date, so they do not share in growth after they left.
The cliff is not a hurdle
A cliff is sometimes called an earning threshold, but it is about time, not value: during the first period nothing vests. It limits the risk of someone leaving early, not the cost of the plan.
Choices
How to set them
- Use a hurdle if you want to reward growth from now on, and phantom shares if you want people to share in the full value, for example key people who were there from the start.
- Set the cap well above the value you expect in a good scenario. It is a safety net, not a target.
- Calculate at least three scenarios: disappointing, expected and very good. Check that the plan still feels fair in each.
- Explain the cap in euros. "Your grant can be worth up to €40,000" is clearer than any formula.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. The figures in this article are an illustration, not a forecast.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
How SARs work, when they fit your plan, and how they let participants benefit from share price growth without receiving actual shares.
Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs): reward value growth
How SARs work, when they fit your plan, and how they let participants benefit from share price growth without receiving actual shares.
How big to make the pool and how much one employee gets: work backwards from the company you want to be, and keep room for later grants.
How many shares should you grant employees?
How big to make the pool and how much one employee gets: work backwards from the company you want to be, and keep room for later grants.