Can you compensate a lower salary with virtual shares?

    A strong candidate, a tight budget and a gap between the two. When virtual shares can bridge that gap, and when they cannot.

    7 min read

    You have found the right person, but you cannot match the salary a large company offers. Or you can, but only by stretching your cash flow in a year where you would rather invest. Then the question comes up: can we pay a little less in salary and offer virtual shares instead?

    In short: yes, as long as everyone understands that virtual shares are a variable reward that follows the value of the company. They can make a lower salary acceptable for someone who believes in where the company is going. They are never a fixed replacement for salary, and the base salary always stays within the legal limits.

    The context

    Why the question comes up so often

    Growing companies compete for the same people as large employers, often with less room in their budget. Cash is needed for growth, hiring and product, while the value the company is building only becomes visible later. Virtual shares let you share that future value today, without spending cash now.

    The same question also comes up with freelancers and service providers who agree to a lower rate in exchange for a share in the growth. The logic is the same: a lower fixed amount now, a variable reward later.

    One nuance is worth stating, because it changes how the conversation goes. A strong hire is itself an investment. Someone who moves the company forward is worth what they cost, so the grant is not compensation for a shortfall: it is a share in the value that person helps to create.

    The key difference

    Salary is certain, virtual shares are not

    Salary arrives every month, whatever happens. Virtual shares follow the value of the company. That value can rise sharply, but it can also stay flat or fall. Until a payout actually takes place, the value of a grant keeps moving with the company.

    That is why "we keep back €800 a month and give you €800 a month in shares" is the wrong way to present it. It suggests a fixed exchange rate that does not exist. A better way to put it: you give up some certainty today, and in return you share in the value you help to build.

    How people weigh that differs. Some prefer more long-term upside for less cash now. Others are risk averse, or simply need more cash today for personal reasons. Neither position is wrong, and it is worth understanding where someone stands before you put the trade-off on the table.

    The starting value makes a difference

    What a participant shares in depends on the type of virtual shares. With virtual shares that follow the full value, someone shares in today's value as well. With stock appreciation rights, someone only shares in the growth above a starting value. Choose this consciously, because it determines how much of the gap a grant can realistically close.

    Worked example

    Worked example: €800 a month less

    Say a candidate could earn €5,000 a month elsewhere. You offer €4,200 a month plus stock appreciation rights that are financially equal to 0.5% of the shares, with today's value of €4 million as the starting value. Over five years, the candidate gives up €48,000 in gross salary. What the grant is worth after five years depends on the value of the company:

    Company value after 5 yearsValue of the grantCompared with €48,000 salary
    Value stays €4 million€0€48,000 less
    Value doubles to €8 million€20,000€28,000 less
    Value triples to €12 million€40,000€8,000 less
    Value grows to €20 million€80,000€32,000 more

    The amounts are before tax and before any hurdles, caps or other terms in the plan. The example shows what matters most: the grant only makes up for the salary given up when the company grows strongly. That is not a reason to avoid the trade-off. It is a reason to make it visible upfront, so the candidate chooses it with open eyes.

    Boundaries

    Boundaries you cannot trade away

    However attractive the grant, some things are not up for negotiation:

    • Minimum wage and collective agreements. The base salary never goes below the statutory minimum wage or a binding collective agreement. Virtual shares come on top of that.
    • Existing employees. Salary is part of the employment terms. An employer cannot lower it on its own, so a lower salary in exchange for virtual shares only works if the employee agrees.
    • Knock-on effects. A lower salary can also mean less holiday pay, a lower pension accrual and lower benefits in case of illness or unemployment. Mention this, so nobody is surprised later.
    • Tax. Salary and virtual shares are taxed differently and at different moments. Have your own adviser check what the trade-off means in your situation.

    Also keep the grant out of the employment contract itself. A separate participation agreement under the plan rules keeps the variable reward apart from fixed pay, which keeps things clear for both sides.

    Structure

    How to structure the trade-off

    Grant from day one

    When virtual shares are part of the reason someone accepts a lower salary, it makes sense to grant them at the start rather than after a waiting period. A grant for new hires, often called an acquisition grant, does exactly that. If the trade-off is a recurring part of your hiring, take it into account when you decide how large the pool should be.

    Vesting and leaver rules

    With vesting, someone builds up their rights over a number of years, often with a cliff in the first year. Leaver rules set out what someone keeps when they leave. For someone who accepted a lower salary, it is reasonable that the rights already built up stay in place when they leave on good terms. Agree that upfront.

    Plan the moment the salary catches up

    A lower salary is often meant for a phase, for example until the next funding round or until the company is profitable. Agree when you will look at the salary again, and that the grant simply stays in place when the salary goes up. That keeps the trade-off fair over time.

    Communication

    Explaining it honestly

    The trade-off works when the candidate understands what they are agreeing to. Explain how the starting value was set, show what the grant could be worth in euros under several outcomes, and include the outcome in which the salary given up is not earned back. A candidate who chooses this knowingly is more committed than one who was promised a future fortune.

    After signing, keep it visible. In Sharesquare every participant has their own dashboard showing what they have built up, how their vesting is progressing and what their grant could mean in euros under different outcomes. That way the reason they accepted a lower salary does not disappear into a drawer.

    Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. Have the salary change, the plan and its tax treatment reviewed by your own advisers.

    Insights

    Frequently asked questions

    Want to see what a grant is worth next to the salary?

    Model grants and outcomes in euros, so every candidate sees what they give up and what they could gain. Try the tool for free or book an intro call.