Good leaver and bad leaver: what happens when someone leaves
No company keeps everyone forever, including people with virtual shares. What matters, is how you deal with it upfront, so the plan stays fair for those who stay.
On this page
A virtual share plan is meant for the long term. But nobody is obliged to stay, and sometimes the company is the one ending the relationship. Leaver rules (in legal terms, leaver provisions) decide what happens to someone's virtual shares in that case. They are almost always part of a plan, and they are one of the parts people read most closely.
Fairness
Why a plan needs leaver rules
Take someone who leaves after six loyal years, a year before the company is sold. Part of the value at that sale was built by them, so it is fair that they share in it. Now take someone who is dismissed because they took money from the company. Few people would argue that they should still receive a payout.
Leaver rules make that difference upfront, in writing. That has two effects. People who want to leave have a reason to do so in good consultation. And the people who stay know that value they build is not shared with people who left on bad terms.
Bad leaver
The bad leaver
A bad leaver usually loses all virtual shares, vested or not. The plan lists the events that make someone a bad leaver. Common ones are:
- dismissal for urgent cause under local employment law;
- a breach of confidentiality, a non-compete or a non-solicitation clause;
- selling, transferring or pledging the virtual shares, which the plan does not allow.
One thing is important here: the bad leaver label is not a tool to save money. It only applies to the events in the plan. If there is a dispute, the company has to be able to explain why the rule applies. A plan that is used against people loses its value for everyone else in the team.
Good leaver
The good leaver
A good leaver leaves on good terms: they resign, retire or the company ends the contract without any fault on their side. The unvested virtual shares lapse and go back to the pool. For the vested part there are roughly four options:
- Keep, with a capped value. The person keeps the vested virtual shares, but their value is capped at the value on the leaving date. They are paid when the payout trigger takes place. This is the most common choice.
- Keep, with unvesting. The person keeps the vested virtual shares at first, but loses them gradually over a set period.
- Buy back. The company buys back the vested virtual shares at the current value, or at a discount. That settles it right away, but it does cost cash.
- Keep, fully. The vested virtual shares keep growing in value until the payout. That is generous, and it means someone who left still shares in growth they no longer contribute to.
Valuation
A fair price at leaving
If you cap the value at the leaving date, you need a way to set that value. There are three common routes:
A company value you set
The board sets a company value that serves as the cap. Simple, as long as the valuation is explained.
Transactions around the leaving date
The cap follows the price in a funding round or share transfer that takes place around the leaving date, also shortly after it. That price was paid by someone else, so it is hard to dispute.
A formula
The cap follows a formula, for example a multiple of profit. That is predictable, but the details matter: check that the formula still gives a fair outcome in a good and in a bad year.
Whichever route you take, the cap only works downwards. If the company is worth less at the payout than on the leaving date, the lower value applies.
Variations
Other leaver types
Some plans add a third type, such as a standard or early leaver. That covers situations that are neither clearly good nor bad, for example when someone can no longer manage their own affairs. Others go the other way and use one leaver type for everyone.
Simpler is often better. Every extra type is an extra discussion on the day someone leaves.
Death and long term illness are worth a separate look. In most plans, a participant who passes away counts as a good leaver, and the heirs receive the payout when the payout trigger takes place.
Checklist
Checklist for your leaver rules
- The bad leaver events are listed, specific and linked to clauses that exist in the employment or service contract.
- You have chosen what a good leaver keeps: vested only, with or without a value cap.
- You know how the value at leaving is set, and who decides.
- Death, long term illness and retirement have a clear outcome.
- A participant can explain the rules in their own words after reading them once.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal or tax advice. Have the leaver rules for your company reviewed by a lawyer.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
How a 'good leaver' approach holds up legally, why full forfeiture is risky, and what best practice looks like in the agreement.
An employee passes away: what to do with their virtual shares?
How a 'good leaver' approach holds up legally, why full forfeiture is risky, and what best practice looks like in the agreement.
What vesting means, how cliff and graded schedules work, and how to design vesting that keeps employees committed.
Vesting explained: keep people aligned over time
What vesting means, how cliff and graded schedules work, and how to design vesting that keeps employees committed.