Icon of a simple corporate structure

    Virtual shares in a group: granting company vs tracked company

    In a group of legal entities, decide two things: which entity pays out and which entity's value counts.

    6 min read

    In a single company, a virtual share plan is simple: the company that employs you is also the company whose value you share in. But it happens regularly that a business grows into several legal entities. A company at the top, one or more operating companies below it, sometimes a company per country. Then you have to decide which entity does what.

    Basics

    Two roles: paying and tracking

    • The granting company makes the promise and pays out. It is the participant's counterparty: when the payout comes, the participant has a claim against this company.
    • The tracked company is the company whose progress sets the amount: its value for a share in value growth, or its profit for a share in the yearly profit.

    In a single company both roles fall on the same entity. In a group, they can be split.

    Tracking

    Which company do you track?

    The number of virtual shares is compared with the real share capital of the tracked company. So the question is: whose value should participants share in? Two things help you decide.

    Where people make a difference

    Track the company whose results the participants really influence. A management team that works for the whole group fits the company at the top. A team that only builds one business may feel more connected to that operating company.

    An example: a restaurant chain where every location is its own legal entity. Opening a new location often means the manager, the chef and the head waiter of an existing restaurant have to move there temporarily to get it up and running. That is not always convenient or desirable for them. If the tracked company is the top of the chain instead of their own location, they share in the success of the whole group, which gives them a real reason to help build that new location.

    What would be sold

    At a payout you need a clear value. If buyers would take over the group as a whole, the company at the top has a clear price on that day. If one operating company could be sold on its own, tracking it means its value is known when that happens. In both cases, the valuation of the tracked company is what drives the grant.

    Paying

    Which company pays?

    The granting company is usually the participant's own employer or client. That keeps the relationship clear: the company that pays salary or fees also makes the promise. A group can have several granting companies, each for its own people, while all of them track the same company.

    Check upfront that the granting company can pay when the time comes. At a sale of the company at the top, the purchase price goes to the shareholders, not to the operating company that employs the participants. How the payout is funded is something to agree with the buyer in the deal.

    Checklist

    Points to check

    • The owner's personal company. If the owners hold their shares through a personal company, that is usually not the company to track. Track the company where the business value sits.
    • Moves inside the group. State what happens to a grant when someone moves to another group company, so it does not count as leaving.
    • Changes in the structure. A restructuring, merger or a new company at the top can change which company is tracked. Agree in the plan how grants follow such a change.
    • One name for the group. Participants often know the brand, not the legal entities. Use that name in the explanation, and the legal names in the contract.

    Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. Have the structure of your plan within the group reviewed by your own advisers.

    Insights

    Frequently asked questions

    Set up your group structure once

    In Sharesquare you enter which company is tracked and which companies grant, and every contract and calculation follows from that.