Virtual shares without an exit: how participants still get paid
Not every company is built to be sold. A virtual share plan can still give people a real reward, through a share of the profit or a buyback at set moments.
On this page
Many explanations of virtual shares end with the same moment: the company is sold, and participants receive their share. But plenty of companies have no plans to sell. They are profitable, family owned or simply happy to stay independent. For them, a plan that only pays at an exit feels like a promise for a day that never comes.
The problem
Why most plans wait for an exit
A virtual share is a promise of value. When it pays out, the company has to turn that promise into cash. At an exit, that cash comes from the buyer. Without an exit, it has to come from the company itself, and money spent on payouts cannot be spent on people, product or growth at the same time.
That is why most plans name the exit as the payout moment. It is not the only option, as long as you design the alternative upfront.
Payout moments
Three moments that can pay out
- An external liquidity event. Shares are sold to a third party or the company is listed. Shareholders receive money, and participants are paid too.
- A dividend moment. The company pays out part of its yearly profit to its shareholders, and to its virtual shareholders.
- A buyback. The company uses its own funds to buy back virtual shares and pays cash for them.
A plan without an exit builds on the second and third.
Profit
A share of the yearly profit
With a virtual dividend, participants receive a share of the profit every year. Think of the profit as a pie. The plan treats virtual shares as if they were real shares, so each participant receives the slices that match their number of virtual shares.
The annual accounts set the number
The basis is the profit in the adopted annual accounts. Those are usually ready in the first half of the next year, so the payout follows the year it relates to. That is calm and predictable, and participants see a direct link between this year's results and next year's payout.
Combined with value growth
A profit share and a share of the value at a later sale can sit in one plan. Then people receive something every year and still benefit if the company is sold one day. If you use vesting, usually only the vested virtual shares count for the profit share.
Buyback
Buying back virtual shares
In a buyback, the company opens a window in which participants can sell part of their virtual shares back, at a value set according to the plan. You decide upfront:
- When. Every year or quarter, after a set period, or at an event such as someone leaving.
- How much per person. A maximum percentage of their vested virtual shares.
- How much in total. A budget per round. If requests exceed the budget, not everyone is bought back in full.
Balance is the key word. A buyback is a short term moment inside a long term plan. If people can sell very little, it feels symbolic. If they can sell almost everything, there is little left to keep them engaged in the years after.
Cash
Where the money comes from
Without an exit, every payout comes out of the company's own cash. That works best for companies with a stable profit. A practical approach is to set money aside every year for future payouts, so a buyback round never competes with salaries or investments.
Is the profit still uncertain? Then start with a modest budget and keep the exit as the main payout moment. A plan can always become more generous later, while taking a promise back is much harder. For value growth without a sale, stock appreciation rights with a buyback are a common combination.
End date
A plan that does not run forever
A plan without a clear end can stay open for decades. A longstop period solves that: after a set number of years without a payout moment, the plan ends. If a payout moment does take place before then, participants are paid and the plan continues as agreed. Choose a period that fits your company, and explain it at the start so nobody is surprised.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. Have the payout rules and their tax treatment checked by your own advisers.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
How profit sharing works: which profit pool you use, which KPIs it is tied to, when you pay out and what it costs.
Profit sharing and virtual dividend: share the profit every year
How profit sharing works: which profit pool you use, which KPIs it is tied to, when you pay out and what it costs.
How SARs work, when they fit your plan, and how they let participants benefit from share price growth without receiving actual shares.
Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs): reward value growth
How SARs work, when they fit your plan, and how they let participants benefit from share price growth without receiving actual shares.