Virtual shares and SARs vs a STAK: which fits, and how to combine them

    A STAK gives real economic ownership with concentrated voting. A virtual share plan gives a contractual right to value. Often the honest answer is both.

    14 min read

    A STAK is the classic Dutch way to let people share in company value: a foundation holds the shares and issues depositary receipts, so economic rights move while voting stays in one place. A virtual share plan, often called a VSOP or SAR plan, does something different: it gives people a contractual right to a cash payout linked to company value, without touching the shares at all. This page compares the two on ownership, governance, administration and cost, and then shows how to combine them: four common setups, what to align when you run both, and how to involve SAR holders. That covers the situation many Dutch companies are actually in: a STAK already exists, and the question is what to do for everyone who is not in it.

    Part 1

    What a STAK actually is

    A STAK (stichting administratiekantoor, in English usually called a trust office foundation) is a Dutch foundation that holds shares in a company and issues depositary receipts (certificaten) to participants.

    The split is the whole point. The foundation stays the legal shareholder and exercises the voting rights through its board. The receipt holders get the economic rights: their share of dividends and of the proceeds when the company is sold. The relationship is documented in administration conditions (administratievoorwaarden) that set out how receipts are issued, valued, transferred and bought back.

    Because a STAK works with real shares, setting it up involves a notary, a shareholder resolution, an amendment to the articles where needed, and a transfer of shares to the foundation. After that, the foundation is a standing entity with a board, a register of receipt holders and its own obligations.

    A STAK separates economic rights from voting rights. It works with real shares, so every step is a corporate and notarial act.

    Part 2

    What virtual shares and SARs are

    Virtual shares are contractual rights that track company value without issuing real equity. A participant holds an agreement, not a share, and receives a cash payout when a defined event occurs, typically an exit, a dividend distribution or a scheduled buy-back moment.

    Within that family, Stock Appreciation Rights are the appreciation only variant: the payout is the value increase since the grant date, so the value already built stays with the existing owners. Full value grants track the entire value of the underlying virtual share, and a virtual dividend variant shares distributed profit.

    A plan of this type is often called a VSOP or SAR plan (virtual stock option plan). It is created by contract, so no notary, no share transfer and no change in the shareholder register is involved. Rules on vesting, leavers, caps and payout triggers are written into the plan document rather than into the corporate structure.

    Virtual shares are contractual, not corporate. Nothing moves in the share register.

    Part 3

    Ownership, voting and the cap table

    Under a STAK, receipt holders are economic co-owners. They carry the value of the shares and, depending on the administration conditions, they may have meeting rights, information rights and a position that continues after they leave the company unless the conditions say otherwise. Voting stays with the foundation board, which is what keeps decision making concentrated.

    Under a VSOP or SAR plan, the shareholder base is unchanged. Participants hold a claim against the company, not a stake in it. There is no meeting right, no information right that follows from shareholding, and the position ends when the plan says it ends.

    That difference shows up in due diligence. A STAK produces a foundation, a register of receipt holders and a set of conditions that a buyer will read. A VSOP or SAR plan produces an accrued obligation that has to be quantified and funded at the payout event.

    It also shows up at closing. In a sale, the foundation transfers the shares through its board, but the administration conditions decide what happens to the receipts: whether receipt holders have to consent, how they are bought out and how the foundation is wound down. If some holders left years ago, are hard to reach or disagree with the deal, or if receipts passed to heirs after a death, that takes time at exactly the moment a buyer wants to move. Under a VSOP or SAR plan the shareholders sell as they otherwise would, and the plan is settled as a payment by the company under its own rules. Read more about what a buyer looks at in a participation plan.

    With a STAK the economic ownership genuinely changes hands. With a VSOP or SAR plan it does not, which is exactly why some companies choose one over the other.

    Part 4

    What each route asks of the company and the participant

    For the company, a STAK means corporate work: incorporation of the foundation, notarial acts, administration conditions, a board that has to be staffed and kept independent enough to do its job, a receipt holder register, and a valuation basis for every issue and buy-back. Each new participant is a corporate step, not an administrative one.

    For the participant, receipts are an asset that is usually acquired at fair value. That can mean paying for the position, or being taxed on the benefit if it is received below value. It also means holding an illiquid asset for as long as the company stays private.

    A VSOP or SAR plan shifts the weight. Granting is a contractual act, so adding participants is fast and can be done across borders without local share transfer formalities. Participants put in no money and take no downside. For employees the payout runs through payroll. In return, the company carries a future cash obligation that has to be modelled and funded when the trigger event arrives.

    A STAK is heavier to set up and to maintain. A VSOP or SAR plan is lighter to run but creates a cash obligation the company has to be able to pay.

    Part 5

    Can participants afford to buy in?

    STAK receipts represent real economic ownership, so participants normally have to acquire them at fair value. That means putting in capital, or at least being taxed on a benefit if the receipts are issued below value. Not every employee, adviser or later hire has that capacity, and not everyone wants to take the investment risk of an illiquid private-company position.

    A VSOP or SAR plan avoids this entirely. Grants cost the participant nothing upfront, there is no acquisition moment, and the payout only happens if the trigger events in the plan are met. That makes a virtual share plan feasible for a much wider group, including people who cannot or do not want to invest their own money.

    STAK receipts have to be paid for; virtual shares and SARs do not. That alone determines who can realistically participate.

    Part 6

    Tax and cost, at a high level

    The two routes sit in different tax logics. Receipts in a STAK are treated as an interest in shares, so the questions are about the acquisition value, the holder's position and how gains are treated when the receipts are sold or bought back. Acquiring below fair value while employed generally creates a taxable benefit at that moment. Because that value is set at issue, the tax authorities can also test it afterwards. If they consider the price too low, wage tax can still be assessed, sometimes years later, and that assessment lands with the employer.

    A VSOP or SAR plan payout is cash from the company, so it is normally treated as employment income at the moment it is paid, and it is usually a deductible expense for the company. Nothing is taxable for the participant while the plan runs, because nothing has been received, and there is no purchase price to defend at grant, because nothing changes hands.

    We do not calculate tax and this is not tax advice. Treatment depends on local legislation, on the participant's personal situation and on the structure chosen, so it is worth checking early with a local tax adviser. Sharesquare works with partners who do this.

    The routes are taxed on different principles, which is why the choice is rarely purely legal.

    Part 7

    Leavers and the dead equity problem

    When someone leaves a STAK, their depositary receipts usually stay with them unless the administration conditions force a buy-back. If the company does not have the cash to buy the person out, the receipts remain outstanding. The leaver then continues to share in future dividends and exit proceeds without contributing to the company any more. That is the classic dead equity problem, and it is especially painful when the company's value is mostly on paper.

    With a VSOP or SAR plan the position is contractual, so the plan can define exactly what stops and what pays out on departure. Unvested rights fall away. Vested appreciation rights can be capped or frozen at a fixed value. Virtual dividend rights can end when employment ends. The company only pays when the plan says it pays, typically at an exit, so no cash is trapped in a buy-out and no former participant stays attached to future value indefinitely.

    A STAK can leave former participants attached to future value; a VSOP or SAR plan can cut that tie cleanly.

    Part 8

    STAK certificates and SARs side by side

    The differences above in one overview, before you choose.

    STAK certificatesSARs
    What the participant getsDividends and a part of the sale proceedsCash equal to the value growth above the hurdle
    Buy inUsually pays a priceNothing to buy
    VotingExercised by the STAK boardNone
    What you needFoundation, board, administration conditions, notarial deed for the sharesPlan document and participant agreement
    On leavingCertificates usually offered back and valuedThe leaver rules in the plan
    Across bordersDutch structure, less familiar abroadContractual, works in any country
    FitsPeople who invest and stay for the long termA broad group, including freelancers and team abroad

    Part 9

    When a STAK is the stronger choice

    A STAK tends to fit when:

    • You want a small group of people to be real economic owners, not to receive a cash bonus that tracks value.
    • Dutch shareholders, family members or long term partners are being brought in and voting has to stay concentrated.
    • Participants are able and willing to acquire their position at value, or a financing route exists for them.
    • The structure is meant to last for years and to survive changes in management.
    • A local tax regime treats a shareholding position more favourably than employment income for the people involved.

    The trade-off is weight: every issue, transfer and buy-back is a corporate act, and the foundation has to be governed properly for as long as it exists.

    A STAK fits when real economic ownership is genuinely part of the offer.

    Part 10

    When virtual shares, a VSOP or SAR plan are the stronger choice

    Virtual shares tend to fit when:

    • You want to include a broader group, including people who join later, without a corporate act each time.
    • Participants should not be asked to invest their own money or to hold an illiquid asset.
    • You grant across several countries and need one framework that can be documented contractually.
    • You want to shape the outcome precisely: appreciation only, full value, profit sharing, caps, hurdles, good and bad leaver treatment.
    • The cap table and the shareholder register have to stay unchanged.

    The trade-off is that participants do not become owners in any legal sense, so the plan has to be transparent enough to still feel real: a clear valuation basis, visible vesting and a personal overview people can actually open.

    A VSOP or SAR plan fits when you want reach, speed and predictable rules without touching the corporate structure.

    Part 11

    Using a STAK and a VSOP or SAR plan together

    In practice these instruments are often used together, and that is where the STAK versus VSOP or SAR plan framing breaks down. Put simply: a certificate is a stake the holder usually pays for, a SAR is a reward for the growth created from the grant onwards. Those answer two different questions, and often for different people.

    Management invests, the wider team shares in the growth

    The STAK holds the positions of the founders, early partners and a handful of key people who genuinely acquired ownership. A VSOP or SAR plan is then added for the wider team, for later hires and for freelancers or advisers who should share in growth but do not belong in the foundation. Nobody has to be added to the receipt holder register, and everyone has a reason to build value at a level of commitment that fits their role.

    The STAK already exists, SARs are added

    Some companies already have a STAK, for example for succession or a group of investors. A SAR plan for employees can be added next to it, without changing the foundation or its administration conditions. The STAK keeps doing what it was set up to do.

    Certificates at home, SARs abroad

    A STAK is a Dutch structure. For team members in other countries a contractual SAR is usually easier to explain and to run through local payroll, while the Dutch core team can still hold certificates.

    SARs first, a buy in later

    A company runs a VSOP or SAR plan first, because it is quick to launch and easy to explain, and offers certificates to a selected group later, when the intention to give real ownership is clear. A SAR does not convert by itself: the buy in is a separate decision. So before anyone moves into ownership, write down how the valuation works, what happens to the vesting already earned, and whether the SAR is settled at that moment or keeps running.

    Using both also lets you calibrate the message. Receipts say partner. A virtual share plan says you share in the growth you help create. Different groups often need different answers, and one structure rarely gives both.

    STAK

    • Participant invests money
    • Taxed as capital gains
    • Dead equity risk for the company

    Great for key employees

    VSOP / SAR

    • Risk free for both, very flexible
    • Taxed as income, deductible for company
    • Usually higher tax for the participant

    Great for a larger group of employees

    STAK compared to a VSOP or SAR plan

    • STAK: Participant invests money, Taxed as capital gains, Dead equity risk for the company. Great for key employees.
    • VSOP / SAR: Risk free for both, very flexible, Taxed as income, deductible for company, Usually higher tax for the participant. Great for a larger group of employees.
    The two are not mutually exclusive. In practice a STAK often serves a small inner circle and a VSOP or SAR plan serves everyone else.

    Part 12

    What to align when you run both

    Running a STAK and a SAR plan side by side works as long as the two never contradict each other. Five things to settle up front:

    • One valuation. Use the same method and the same moments for certificates and SARs. Two groups seeing two values of the same company is the fastest way to lose trust.
    • Who carries the SAR payout. A SAR payout is a company cost, so at a sale it reduces what is left for shareholders, including the STAK and its certificate holders. Show this in an example before anyone signs, so nobody is surprised at closing.
    • The same leaver language. Use the same good leaver and bad leaver definitions, so someone holding both is not treated in two ways.
    • The same moment at exit. Describe what happens to certificates and SARs at a sale or change of control, and make sure the timing matches.
    • One explanation. Explain both instruments together, with the same example company, so people understand why they hold what they hold.
    Align the valuation, the leaver rules and the exit treatment, so someone holding both is never treated in two ways.

    Part 13

    Involving SAR holders

    Certificate holders have a formal counterpart: the STAK board, with meetings and information duties. SAR holders have none of that by default, and because they are not certificate holders they are not automatically invited to that meeting either. Without a counterpart, they can quickly feel exposed to one sided decisions. Write the following into the plan:

    • A SAR holders meeting. A recurring session, for example twice a year, on value development, the valuation method and the state of the plan. You can combine it with the information session for certificate holders.
    • Information rights. Which figures participants receive, how often and in how much detail.
    • A limit on changes. Which changes the board can make on its own, and which need consent.
    • A representative. One participant as spokesperson gives the group a single voice towards management.
    SAR holders have no foundation board as a counterpart, so organise their information and consultation in the plan itself.

    Part 14

    Choosing between them

    A practical way to work through it:

    1. Who should genuinely be an owner, and who should share in the value without owning? That question usually splits the group in two by itself.
    2. Can participants realistically acquire a position at value, or would that create a barrier or a tax moment they cannot fund?
    3. How many people will you add over the next few years, in how many countries? Corporate acts per participant scale poorly.
    4. What should happen when someone leaves, and how quickly do you want to be able to settle it?
    5. When can this pay out, and can the company fund it at that moment?
    6. Do you already have a STAK? If so, the real question is usually not which one, but what the STAK should keep doing and what a VSOP or SAR plan should take over.

    If you want to talk this through against your own situation, a short call with us or with one of our legal and tax partners is usually faster than reading another comparison.

    Start with who you want to be an owner and who you want to reward, then pick the structure that matches.

    Insights

    Frequently asked questions

    Want to set up a virtual share plan?

    Sharesquare helps you design, model, and roll out virtual share plans, including SARs and full value grants, without complicating your cap table.