Virtual shares vs stock options: which is right for your company?
A plan level choice: what each instrument does to your cap table, your investors, your admin and the people you want to motivate.
On this page
Virtual shares and stock options are both ways to let your team share in the value they help create. The decision between them is a company decision, not a technical one: it depends on when your shares can realistically be sold, who you want on your cap table and how much legal machinery you are willing to run. This page compares them at plan level. For the instrument level detail, including the payout formula, accounting and tax moments, see our comparison of Stock Appreciation Rights and stock options. Virtual shares are also known as phantom shares or phantom stock. Different name, same mechanics: a contractual right to a cash payout tied to the company value.
Part 1
What virtual shares actually are
Virtual shares is the umbrella term for contractual rights that track company value without issuing real equity. Within that family you can design very different plans:
- Appreciation only, better known as Stock Appreciation Rights: participants receive the value increase since they joined.
- Full value: the payout tracks the whole value of the underlying virtual share, not just the growth.
- Virtual dividend: participants share in distributed profit, with or without an exit linked component.
- Buy-back settlement: the company repurchases the virtual position at the then current valuation, so people can see money before an exit.
A stock option, by contrast, is one shape: the right to buy real shares at a fixed price. Everything you want to do differently has to be built around that shape.
Virtual shares are a design space, not a single product. That is the main thing stock options cannot offer.
Part 2
What a stock option actually is
A stock option is the right, not the obligation, to buy a fixed number of real shares at a price set on the grant date (the strike or exercise price). That right usually vests over time, and it only becomes valuable if the company is worth more later than it was at grant.
To turn an option into money the participant has to take two steps. First exercise: pay the strike price and actually become a shareholder. Then sell: find a buyer, which in a private company normally means waiting for an exit or a secondary round. Between those two steps the participant holds real shares, with shareholder rights, but also with money at risk.
Three things define how an option plan behaves in practice: the exercise price, the exercise window (how long someone has to exercise, especially after leaving), and the expiry date. In many jurisdictions there is also a tax moment at exercise, before any cash has been received.
An option is a right to buy, not an award of value. Everything about it, timing, cost and tax, follows from that.
Part 3
Real equity versus a contractual right
A contractual right such as a virtual share tracks the same economic upside without changing ownership, and it can be amended as the company changes.
The trade-off is that participants never become shareholders, and any payout is only due if predefined events occur - such as a dividend, an exit, or another liquidity moment - and only to the extent money is actually available. Which side of that trade-off is preferable depends on the jurisdiction, the shareholder base and how liquid the shares realistically are. In many jurisdictions, capital-gains tax on real shares is also lower than the income tax that applies to a virtual-share payout, which can make a meaningful difference in net proceeds.
Much of the friction in option plans comes from the shares themselves, not from the incentive.
Part 4
What each side sees
For the company, options mean legal dilution and governance work, while virtual shares mean an accrued cash obligation at a defined moment. Both are a real cost, and both need to be modelled. The difference is that one permanently changes who owns the business and the other creates a liability the company has to be able to fund.
For the participant, an option means committing money to exercise, tracking exercise windows and expiry dates, and eventually finding a buyer. A virtual share means a cash payout at a trigger event, with no personal investment, but also no shareholder rights and no ability to hold the position after the payout. In companies where shares are hard to sell, virtual shares are usually easier to explain and to value. Where shares are liquid, stock options can be worth considerably more.
Companies weigh dilution against a future cash obligation. Participants weigh ownership against the ability to actually realise value.
Part 5
Investor and governance perspective
Investors generally accept an employee incentive pool. The common objections concern a fragmented register, minority shareholders with information rights, and obligations that surface late in due diligence.
An option pool is familiar and easy to benchmark, which is why many investors default to it. A virtual share plan keeps the register unchanged and turns the incentive into a documented liability at exit, which is straightforward to model in a term sheet but less standardised across markets. Either way the plan, the base values, the vesting and the leaver treatment have to be administered properly, because a buyer will read all of it.
The debate is rarely about the incentive itself. It is about the register, the modelling and the surprises in due diligence.
Part 6
When virtual shares are the stronger choice
Virtual shares tend to be the better instrument when:
- You want to keep the cap table unchanged and avoid the governance work that comes with minority shareholders.
- Participants should not be asked to put in personal cash or track exercise windows and expiry dates.
- You want flexibility in what the plan pays out: growth only, full value, profit sharing, or a buy-back settlement.
- You are granting across several jurisdictions and need an instrument that can be documented contractually without local share-transfer formalities.
- Local tax treatment makes a cash-settled payout simpler or more predictable for the people who receive it.
The trade-off is that participants do not become shareholders, so the plan has to be designed carefully to still feel like real ownership.
Virtual shares work best when liquidity is uncertain and simplicity matters.
Part 7
When stock options are the stronger choice
Stock options tend to be the better instrument when:
- The company is listed or an IPO is realistically near, so participants can sell shares to cover the exercise price and any tax due.
- There is a functioning secondary market or a recurring structured liquidity event.
- Real ownership is part of what you want to offer, for example to a small group of key people who want to be shareholders.
- A local tax regime treats option gains materially more favourably than cash taxed as salary. Several countries have specific option regimes with reduced rates or deferred taxation. In the Netherlands, a bill for startups and scale-ups proposes such a regime, limited to companies with an RVO decision and to options that meet strict conditions.
Where shares cannot realistically be sold for years, the same instrument asks participants to invest their own money in an illiquid asset, which is why some companies look at cash settled alternatives instead.
Liquidity is the deciding variable. With tradeable shares options can outperform, without them they are harder to realise.
Part 8
Choosing a plan type
A practical way to decide:
- When can this realistically pay out? If the honest answer is only at an exit in several years, an instrument that requires no personal investment in the meantime is easier to make credible.
- Do you want people to share in growth only, or in profit as well? Appreciation only points to SARs, profit sharing points to a virtual dividend component.
- Will you keep granting as the valuation rises? Then per grant base values matter, and so does how much work each new grant creates.
- Does the cap table have to stay unchanged, and does your jurisdiction make share transfers heavy or light? That answer often settles the question on its own.
- How does each route get taxed for both the participant and the company in the countries where your people are employed? This varies widely and is worth checking early with a local adviser.
For the instrument level detail, including the payout formula, accounting and tax moments, read our comparison of Stock Appreciation Rights and stock options.
Start with the outcome you want people to feel, then pick the instrument that can deliver it.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
SARs and options reward the same value growth. Compare payout mechanics, cash needed, dilution, tax moment and administration.
Stock appreciation rights vs stock options
SARs and options reward the same value growth. Compare payout mechanics, cash needed, dilution, tax moment and administration.
The five most common forms of employee participation, side by side. When to use each one, notary or not, voting rights and cash upfront.
5 ways to reward employees with equity: KPI bonus, virtual shares, options, STAK, shares
The five most common forms of employee participation, side by side. When to use each one, notary or not, voting rights and cash upfront.