Skin in the game: how virtual shares give your team a real stake
People who share in the results think differently about their work. How to make that happen without anyone having to invest their savings first.
On this page
Almost every leadership team recognises the difference. There are people who do their job well, and there are people who act as if it is their own company. They look beyond their own role, think about costs and opportunities, and stay when times get tough. That difference often has a name: skin in the game.
You cannot force that feeling. You can make it possible, by letting people truly share in what they build together.
The idea
What skin in the game really means
Skin in the game means you personally feel the outcome. When the company does well, so do you. When it does less well, you notice that too. That connection is the difference between thinking along because you have to and thinking along because it matters to you. Without it, you get what economists call the principal-agent problem.
That connection can come about in different ways. Someone can invest their own money, share in the profit, or grow with the value of the company. These are not opposites. They are different routes to the same goal, and each route suits different people and different moments.
Personal investment
Investing your own money: powerful, not required
Someone who puts their own money into a company literally has skin in the game. It is the most direct form of involvement, and for people who can and want to, it works very well. It shows they believe in the company, with their own money.
Make a personal investment a condition for taking part, though, and you shut people out. Think of younger talent, people with a mortgage and a young family, or colleagues who simply have no spare savings. They are often the ones who can make the difference in the years ahead.
With virtual shares, someone shares financially as if they held shares, without buying anything. Their investment is not money but time, effort and the results they help achieve. If someone also wants to invest personally, that is perfectly possible. One does not rule out the other.
Yearly payout
When a yearly payout does work
Not everyone wants to wait five or seven years for a sale that may never come. A yearly payout makes sharing tangible: every year you see what you achieved together. There is nothing wrong with that.
The difference is in the link
A yearly payout loses its power when everyone gets it every year, no matter how things went. It then becomes a fixed part of salary, and the sense of sharing disappears. The same goes for a bonus nobody quite knows the basis of.
It does work when the payout truly follows the profit, under rules everyone knows upfront. A good year means more to share, a weak year less or nothing. That is profit sharing or a virtual dividend: a direct line between the company's result and what someone receives.
The combination
Share today, grow tomorrow
The strongest plans work on two timelines at once. A share of the yearly profit gives a yearly rhythm: people see that their effort this year counts. A share of the growth in value gives a long horizon: those who stay and build share in it when the company becomes worth more, for example at a sale.
A simple worked example. Say the company pays out €200,000 of its profit in a year, and someone holds virtual shares financially equal to 1% of the shares. That person then receives €2,000 that year. If the company is later sold for €10 million, the same stake corresponds to €100,000, before any hurdles or other terms in the plan.
For growth in value without sharing in today's value, stock appreciation rights are a common choice. With those, someone only shares in what is added after the moment they join.
Fairness
Fair for everyone, including those who stay
Skin in the game only works when the rules feel fair, for participants and for shareholders. That takes a few choices upfront:
- Building up over time. With vesting, someone builds up their rights step by step, so commitment over the years is rewarded.
- Leaver rules. You set out what someone keeps when they leave, so the plan stays fair for those who stay.
- Hurdle and cap. A hurdle decides from which value participants start to share, a cap where it stops. That keeps the cost predictable.
Visibility
Visibility makes the difference
A plan that only lives in a contract soon drops out of sight. After a few months nobody quite remembers what their grant means, and then it no longer does anything for engagement. You only feel skin in the game when you see what is at stake.
That is why in Sharesquare every participant gets their own dashboard. There they see what they have built up, how their vesting is progressing and what their grant could mean in euros under different outcomes. You set the rules, the contracts are drafted and signed digitally, and you process changes yourself. That way the plan stays something people look at year after year.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. Have the plan and its tax treatment reviewed by your own advisers.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
The five most common ways to incentivize employees, side by side. When to use each one, notary or not, voting rights and cash upfront.
5 ways to incentivize employees: from KPI bonus to real shares
The five most common ways to incentivize employees, side by side. When to use each one, notary or not, voting rights and cash upfront.
How profit sharing works: which profit pool you use, which KPIs it is tied to, when you pay out and what it costs.
Profit sharing and virtual dividend: share the profit every year
How profit sharing works: which profit pool you use, which KPIs it is tied to, when you pay out and what it costs.