Solving the principal-agent problem: how virtual shares help

    Owners want long-term value, teams are paid for this month. Why interests drift apart, and how virtual shares bring them back together.

    6 min read

    Every company that grows beyond its owners runs into the same tension. The people who make the daily decisions are not the people who carry the financial outcome. Economists call this the principal-agent problem.

    In short: the principal-agent problem is the gap between what owners want and what the people working for them are rewarded for. Virtual shares narrow that gap by letting the team share in the growth in value and profit of the company, without changing who owns or controls it.

    The concept

    What the principal-agent problem is

    A principal asks an agent to act on their behalf. In a company, the shareholders are the principal and the management and employees are the agents. Two things make this relationship tricky:

    • Different interests. Owners care about the value of the company over years. Employees care about their salary, workload, career and job security.
    • Different information. The people doing the work know far more about what really happens than the owners or the board can see.

    Nobody needs to act in bad faith for this to cause problems. It is enough that people respond sensibly to how they are rewarded.

    In practice

    Where you see it in a growing company

    • Sales at any price. A team rewarded on revenue closes deals with heavy discounts or customers that will churn within a year.
    • Safe choices. A manager avoids a bold project because failure is personally costly, while success mainly benefits the shareholders.
    • Short horizons. Key people leave just before the value they helped build becomes visible, for example before a sale.
    • Silos. Departments optimise their own targets instead of the result of the company as a whole.

    Traditional rewards

    Why salary and bonuses only solve part of it

    Salary rewards being there. It is essential for security, but it does not change with the value of the company. A bonus rewards targets, which works well for things you can measure in one year. The catch is that whatever you do not measure tends to get less attention, and next year's result can be sacrificed for this year's number.

    Neither instrument ties people to the outcome the owners care about most: a company that is worth more in five years than it is today.

    The solution

    How virtual shares close the gap

    Virtual shares give participants a financial stake in the same outcome as the shareholders. When the company grows in value or distributes profit, participants benefit too. When it does not, they do not.

    It is a natural mechanism: people feel closer to what they have a stake in, and they look after what they feel close to. A company is no different. Once people share in the long-term success, they care more about it and are more aware of what matters for it. That is what people mean by having skin in the game.

    Shared outcome, not shared control

    Participants do not become legal shareholders and get no voting rights. The interests align, while decision-making stays where it is. That makes virtual shares a practical fit for companies that want alignment without reorganising ownership.

    A longer horizon

    Because the value of a grant follows the company over years, short-term trade-offs become visible to the person making them. A discount that hurts next year's margin also hurts the value of their own grant.

    Value or profit, or both

    Growth in value aligns people with the long term and an eventual sale. A virtual dividend aligns them with the yearly profit. Many plans combine both, so there is something to share in good years and a reason to stay for the long run.

    Design

    Design choices that make or break alignment

    • Vesting. Rights build up over time, which rewards people who stay and contribute.
    • Leaver rules. What someone keeps when they leave determines whether the incentive feels fair and whether it actually keeps people on board.
    • Hurdles and starting value. With stock appreciation rights, people only share in growth above a starting value, so they are rewarded for value they help create.
    • The right group. Include the people whose decisions really move the value of the company, not only the management team.

    Limits

    What virtual shares do not solve

    An incentive only changes behaviour if people understand it. A grant that nobody can explain in euros is a document in a drawer, not an incentive. Virtual shares also do not replace good leadership, clear goals or honest information about how the company is doing: the culture around the plan matters as much as the plan itself.

    That is why in Sharesquare every participant gets a personal dashboard showing their vesting and what their grant could be worth under different outcomes. Keeping the shared outcome visible is what keeps interests aligned after the plan is signed.

    Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. Have your plan and its tax treatment reviewed by your own advisers.

    Insights

    Frequently asked questions

    Want to align your team with the value you are building?

    Design a virtual share plan with vesting, leaver rules and a dashboard per participant. Try the tool for free or book an intro call.