Cliff and accelerated vesting: the two moments that matter most
Most of a vesting schedule runs on its own. Two moments need a deliberate choice: the start, with the cliff, and the end, when a payout comes before the schedule is done.
On this page
Vesting means people earn their virtual shares over time. The basics are covered in vesting explained. This article is about the two moments where a schedule needs a deliberate choice: how it starts, and what happens when a payout comes before it is finished.
The start
The cliff: a safe start
During the cliff, nothing vests. A common cliff is twelve months. Right after it, the part for that whole period vests in one go, and the rest follows step by step.
The cliff works like a safety measure. You can invite people to the plan early, even on their first day. If someone leaves within the cliff, nothing has vested and there is no payment obligation. And it asks a minimum commitment before anyone starts to earn.
The pace
Monthly or yearly after the cliff
After the cliff, virtual shares vest monthly or yearly. The difference shows in an example. Someone receives 1,000 virtual shares on a four year schedule and leaves after 28 months.
- Monthly: 28 of 48 months have passed, so 583 virtual shares have vested.
- Yearly: 2 of 4 years have passed, so 500 virtual shares have vested.
Monthly is most common. Yearly vesting can lead people to sit out the year until the next anniversary, which helps nobody if that is their only reason to stay.
The end
Accelerated vesting: an early payout
Sometimes the payout comes earlier than planned. An offer for the company arrives that is hard to refuse, or circumstances change. Without further rules, participants then only receive the part that has vested. Someone who joined a year ago might see three quarters of their grant lapse at the very moment the value is realised.
That can backfire. A participant who feels the timing is unfair has little reason to help a sale succeed. Accelerated vesting solves that: the schedule speeds up when the payout comes. In a sale, the buyer will also look at this rule, because it affects what the plan costs at closing.
Options
Ways to accelerate
Take a participant who has vested 43% of their grant when the company is sold. Here is how common options play out:
- Full acceleration. Everything vests at once. They receive the full grant.
- Brackets. Vesting jumps to the top of the bracket they are in. With brackets of 25%, 43% becomes 50%.
- Boost. A fixed top up is added. With a boost of 25 points, 43% becomes 68%.
- Discretionary. The company decides at the time whether and how much to accelerate. The decision has to be made before the sale.
- Respecting the cliff. Someone who is still within the cliff at the moment of the sale receives nothing, also with acceleration.
The percentages here are only an example. Show people what each option means in euros for their own grant.
After the sale
Retention after a sale
Acceleration is about the moment of the sale. A buyer also looks at what comes after: they want key people to stay for at least the transition period. If the seller cannot show that, it can weigh on the price.
That is why plans often include a post-exit retention clause: a participant only receives (part of) the payout if they stay with the company for some time after the sale. In the standard Sharesquare plan, the company can make the payout subject to the participant staying for one year after the exit. You can deviate from that by setting:
- which part of the payout is withheld until the retention period ends,
- the maximum retention period,
- who decides whether a participant needs to stay.
Acceleration and retention work well together. Acceleration makes the timing of a sale feel fair, retention makes sure people stay to help the new owner.
Advice
Start simple
Our advice is to keep acceleration out of the plan at the start. It is easy to add later, for example once a sale comes into view, and participants will see it as an improvement. Taking it away later is much harder. A cliff and monthly vesting, on the other hand, are worth deciding on from day one.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. The figures in this article are an illustration.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
What vesting means, how cliff and graded schedules work, and how to design vesting that keeps employees committed.
Vesting explained: keep people aligned over time
What vesting means, how cliff and graded schedules work, and how to design vesting that keeps employees committed.
What a good leaver keeps, when someone is a bad leaver, and how to set a fair value on the day someone leaves.
Good leaver and bad leaver: what happens when someone leaves
What a good leaver keeps, when someone is a bad leaver, and how to set a fair value on the day someone leaves.