Earn-outs and share deals: when the exit is not paid in cash
Not every sale is a single transfer of cash. If the price comes later, depends on results or is paid in shares, the plan rules decide what participants receive and when.
On this page
Most explanations of virtual shares assume a clean exit: the company is sold, the buyer pays, and participants receive their share in cash. Real deals are often less tidy. Part of the price may depend on next year's results, or the sellers receive shares in the buying company. That raises questions a plan should answer upfront.
The basics
How an exit normally pays out
An exit is usually defined as a change of control: a third party buys at least half of the shares. The price per share that the shareholders receive sets the value of each virtual share. The granting company then pays participants in cash.
Deal forms
When the price is not cash on day one
- Earn-out. Part of the price depends on results after the sale, such as revenue or profit in the next two years.
- Deferred payment or escrow. Part of the price is paid later, or held back for a while as security for the buyer.
- Payment in shares. The sellers receive shares in the buyer instead of, or next to, cash.
Earn-out
Earn-outs and deferred payments
The fairest approach is usually to let participants follow the shareholders. They receive a part at closing, based on what was paid then, and a further part each time a later payment comes in. If an earn-out target is not reached, nobody receives that part.
Leavers during the earn-out
An earn-out can run for years, and people may leave in the meantime. Decide upfront whether a good leaver still receives later payments. If the earn-out depends on the team's results, it can make sense to link later payments to staying, and to say so clearly.
Share deal
Paid in shares of the buyer
Virtual shares normally pay out in cash. If the shareholders receive shares in the buyer, there is no cash to pass on, at least not yet. Plans handle this in a few ways:
- Pay in cash anyway, based on the value of the shares received, funded as agreed in the deal.
- Pay later, when the shareholders can sell their new shares.
- Replace the plan with a comparable plan of the buyer, so participants keep sharing in the value of the combined company.
Funding
Who pays the participants
This point is often missed. The participant has a claim against the granting company, usually their employer. In a share sale, however, the price goes to the shareholders, not to that company. So the deal needs to arrange how the payout is funded. Often the cost of the plan is deducted from the price, or the buyer funds it through the company. Either way, the cost is borne by the shareholders in the end. A buyer will check this during due diligence.
Plan rules
What to write in the plan
- What counts as an exit, including whether a partial sale counts.
- What counts as the price: only cash at closing, or also later and non-cash payments.
- When participants are paid: at closing, or in step with the shareholders.
- What happens to people who leave between closing and the last payment.
- How unvested virtual shares are treated, and whether vesting accelerates.
Sharesquare provides software and knowledge, not legal, tax or financial advice. The tax treatment of later or non-cash payments differs by country and situation; ask your own adviser.
Insights
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Two next reads on the same topic.
In an acquisition your plan is opened early. Which documents a buyer asks for, why overhang and leaver history drive the price, and how to stay off the critical path.
What a buyer sees in your employee participation plan
In an acquisition your plan is opened early. Which documents a buyer asks for, why overhang and leaver history drive the price, and how to stay off the critical path.
How the cliff protects the start of a plan, and what happens to unvested shares when a sale comes earlier than expected.
Cliff and accelerated vesting: two moments worth planning for
How the cliff protects the start of a plan, and what happens to unvested shares when a sale comes earlier than expected.